Marriage Equality and More

Beyond Marriage

The Supreme Court of the United States (“SCOTUS”) is set to decide a case that could dramatically alter the marriage law landscape for LGBTQ people. In the next two weeks the Supreme Court will rule in the Obergefell v. Hodges case (in January 2015 the Supreme Court took up freedom to marry cases from four states—Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio and Tennessee—merged them, held oral arguments April 28, and shortly will issue its ruling; for more, see SCOTUSblog’s coverage of the case).

I found the photo above on Facebook in 2013, after Michael Cavadias posted it in response to the LGBTQIA advocacy group Human Rights Campaign (“HRC”) #marriageequality campaign inviting people to “Picture Equality” and show their support for marriage equality by replacing their avatar or profile picture—or superimposing the equal sign on their normal profile pic—with a pink equal sign on a red background, (love + equality). Facebook, Twitter, other social media were awash in red equal signs in late March 2013.

HRC Picture EqualityHRC’s viral campaign, which refers back to the organization’s logo (a gold equal sign on a navy background), had a remarkable impact and a tremendous reach. Of course, people came up with fun creative parodies (Trekkies, Star Wars fans, dog lovers, bacon aficionados, matzoh munchers, etc.—I’ve included two examples at the end of this post.). HRC launched this campaign because of the Supreme Court’s review in March 2013 of two marriage equality-related cases, Edie Windsor’s challenge to the Defense of Marriage Act (“DOMA”) and the other case concerning California’s Proposition 8, a California referendum outlawing same-sex marriage there in 2008.

What’s at stake in the current decision?

This decision could mean that instead of having equal marriage rights in some states and not in others, there could be nationwide marriage equality. Same-sex couples could be recognized at the state level in every state, for tax purposes, healthcare decision-making, and inheritance determinations. At the federal level, same-sex couples join different-sex couples in gaining access to lifeline benefits like Social Security, Veterans spousal benefits, and other programs that when same-sex couples live in states not recognizing same-sex marriage, they are denied. That’s just an abbreviated review; here’s a list of the 1,138 Federal rights, benefits, and privileges that come with marriage. Of course, to really understand why marriage matters, it’s best to explore real people’s stories.

What possible rulings might the Supreme Court deliver?

The Justices of the Supreme Court could choose one of three possible outcomes with their ruling:

  • The Court could rule for the freedom to marry nationwide by declaring that it is unconstitutional to bar same-sex couples from marriage.

  • The Court could rule that non-marriage states must respect marriages legally performed elsewhere, but that those states do not need to issue marriage licenses themselves.

  • The Court could rule that marriage bans do not violate the Constitution and that non-marriage states do not have to respect the legal marriages of same-sex couples.


What does America say?

It should go without saying that civil rights and access to equality for a minority should never be put to a majority vote. That’s why they’re called rights (and not a popularity contest). However, it is heartening to know that the USA has seen some positive change in opinions on same-sex relationship recognition. A recent CNN poll found that “63% of Americans say that gays and lesbians have a constitutional right to marry and have their marriages recognized by the law as valid. That’s up from 49% in August 2010.” Still, 36% of Americans believed that there is no constitutional right to marry for same-sex couples. We await the Justices of the Supreme Court’s ruling.

Beyond Marriage

If the decision is positive, if it grants equality to all American citizens, upholding the constitutional freedom to marry for all, there will still be work to be done for members of the LGBTQIA communities. If the decision is negative, a denial of equal rights to marry across all 50 states, in addition to this disappointment, there will still be work to be done. Basically, there is still a lot of work to be done.

Among the major issues facing the LGBTQIA communities are:


Links of interest

Yoda equality Star Trek Equality


One thought on “Marriage Equality and More

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s